Resources / The Pros and Cons of Paying Car Insurance Premiums Monthly v

The Pros and Cons of Paying Car Insurance Premiums Monthly vs. Annually

5 min read · Updated 28 Aug 2023
Person calculating household expenses

Do you pay car insurance monthly or yearly?

You may be offered monthly instalments or an annual payment, depending on the insurer, policy and eligibility. Paying monthly describes the payment schedule; it does not necessarily make the insurance a one-month contract. Check the policy's effective and expiry dates as well as its payment schedule. The Insurance Bureau of Canada explains premiums and policy periods.

Illustration of blue and silver cars beside a blue protection shield

Should I pay insurance monthly or annually?

Compare the complete cost of both choices and the effect on your available cash. An annual payment may reduce instalment charges where those apply, while monthly payments spread the expense. Neither choice is automatically best for every household. Ask for both totals before deciding.

How to compare the numbers

Write down the annual payment amount, the initial monthly-plan payment, every remaining instalment and all disclosed fees. Add the instalments and fees, then subtract the annual payment amount. That difference is the cost of choosing the payment plan.

Illustration: an annual payment of $2,400 compared with twelve payments of $205 gives a monthly-plan total of $2,460. The difference is $60, or 2.5% of the $2,400 annual price. These are invented comparison figures, not insurer rates or a promised saving.

Can you pay car insurance yearly after starting monthly?

Ask your insurer whether a change is allowed during the current policy term, what balance would be due and whether any charge is refundable. Get the revised payment schedule before cancelling an automatic withdrawal.

Does monthly payment change cancellation rules?

Read the cancellation terms separately from the payment schedule. Monthly instalments should not be treated as a promise that you can end coverage without any amount owing. Ask for the cancellation calculation and arrange replacement coverage before ending a policy you still need.

For Ontario policies, FSRA lists the right to monthly premium instalments among consumer rights and responsibilities. Eligibility and payment-history conditions still need to be checked with the insurer.

Use the savings comparison tool to compare your own annual totals, keeping coverage and deductibles consistent.

This article is general information, not insurance advice. Insurance Genie is not an insurer, brokerage or agency. Coverage is defined by the policy wording issued by the insurer and confirmed by the licensed organization that places it.

Live examples
CRM examples will appear here once the feed is connected.

Car insurance · comparison examples

See what a different premium could mean.

Explore three car insurance illustrations, then compare your own coverage. These assumed amounts show the maths, not available rates or recent customer quotes.

Examples rotate as you browse
Assumed amounts · CAD per year

Illustrative comparison

A car insurance coverage check

10%lower in this illustration
Assumed annual premium
$1,800/yr
Assumed alternative
$1,620/yr
Calculated difference
$180/yr

Keep vehicle, driver, use and coverage details consistent when requesting proposals. Illustrative amounts, not a quote.

Illustrative comparison

A car insurance renewal comparison

27%lower in this illustration
Assumed annual premium
$2,400/yr
Assumed alternative
$1,752/yr
Calculated difference
$648/yr

Compare liability limits, accident benefits, deductibles and optional coverages alongside price. Illustrative amounts, not a quote.

Illustrative comparison

A car insurance deductible conversation

12.5%lower in this illustration
Assumed annual premium
$2,000/yr
Assumed alternative
$1,750/yr
Calculated difference
$250/yr

A different deductible changes your share of a covered loss. Ask for actual options and compare the tradeoff. Illustrative amounts, not a quote.

Illustrations use assumed premiums and are not insurer offers, customer results or guaranteed savings. Compare the same limits, deductibles and coverage before choosing. .

Keep reading

Heavy Equipment Insurance - What It Covers, Costs, and Why You Need It

Learn what heavy equipment insurance covers, how much it may cost, and why contractors need protection for valuable machinery and equipment.

HS Habib Saulat · 14 min

Insurance Broker vs. Insurance Company: What’s the Difference?

Learn the difference between an insurance broker and an insurance company. Compare their roles and find the right coverage with Insurance Genie.

What Does Restaurant Insurance Cover in Ontario?

Learn what restaurant insurance in Ontario may cover, including liability, property damage, equipment, and business interruption coverage.

Questions worth asking

Clear answers to help you compare coverage and prepare for a licensed insurance review.

Is it better to pay car insurance in full or monthly?

Paying car insurance in full vs monthly is a total-cost and cash-flow decision. Add every instalment and fee, compare that total with the annual payment, and keep enough money available for essential expenses and a potential deductible. It may be cheaper to pay insurance annually where instalment charges apply, but ask for both written totals. Car insurance paid monthly can still have a six-month or twelve-month policy term: compare 6 month vs 12 month auto insurance by the actual dates, renewal terms and cancellation calculation, rather than assuming identical commitments.

From Insurance Genie

Recent policy purchases

Explore recent policy purchases shared through our participating insurance professionals.

Recent policies will appear here when the Insurance Genie CRM feed is connected.